The Importance Of Disobeying The Law Can Never Be Justified

In the Crato, Plato seems to argue that disobeying the law can never be justified. I strongly disagree with this statement, while laws serve a purpose in maintaining stability, it is part of human nature to act on personal interest and some laws do not always favor one’s action regardless if it’s justifiable. If a law is preventing certain people or groups from achiveing their interest in survival, equality, and success, than it should be considered justifiable when disobeyed. The notion in forming a society is to preserve freedom and security, without these qualities, than society would be likely to fail. This is how revolutions began by starting with disobyeing the law, and if the outcome of such act benefits towards human progress, than†¦show more content†¦In addition, it is justifiable to disobey a law, one that is unjust. Martin Luther King Jr. describes the essence of his actions by relating it to the most important historical figures such as Socrates, Martin Luther, Jesus, and more. These are people in past events that disobeyed the law, one that they found to be unjust. The statement that Plato is claiming to be true, goes against the actions that these people have made, because they disobeyed the law. If this is in any way a true statemment, it will logically follow that their acts was unjust, therefore, the consequences that they faced is doing justice. I am allowed to deduce this information from the statement, since, it is ambigiuos and to promote justice is to demote injustice. Isn’t an act that improves human personality, a measure of justice. By restating the statement as its contraposivtive: A measure of injustice acts is to degrade human progress. We can see that this logically follows, thus, by disobeying a law can indeed serve justice. Not always but the unjust laws. We see this t hrough historical events, when Martin Luther King Jr. was sent to jail for protesting without a permit. He even accepted the idea of needing a permit to protest but when higher authorites refuses to negociate and ignore his actions, he was forced to take alternative actions that required to break the law. It is these laws thatShow MoreRelatedThe Prevailing Message Throughout Sophocles Antigone And King s Letter From Birmingham Jail1251 Words   |  6 Pagesthat civil disobedience serves the purpose of fighting and correcting injustice in situations where systemic breaks in adherence to natural law occurs. Injustice here as used here is not to be synonymous with things that are simply unlawful or unfair, but instead takes on a deeper and more specific definition pertaining to the natural moral codes that all laws, as argued by King and Antigone, ought to be based upon. It is by this definition that both Antigone and King find reasoning; that civil disobedienceRead MoreThe norms of a society and the way it functions can be reflected in its legal system. This notion600 Words   |  3 Pagessociety and the way it functions can be reflected in its legal system. This notion is significant to Hrafnkel’s Saga as it helps put the death of Einar into perspective. According to Professor Wen, the saga portrays a bloody and messy period of transition between a premodern honor culture and a modern system of law. The legal system of this era reflects a stark contrast from the laws and constitutions of today. In the narrative, Hrafnkel executes Einar for disobeying his orders to refrain from ridingRead MoreThe Truth Behind Political Thought944 Words   |  4 Pagesdemonstrates the importance of natural equality that the rule of law adheres to. Thus creates this inconsistency ,that civil disobedience is not justified because of society s accentuation on law and order. The understanding of law and civil disobedience illustrates itself in both readings of Sophocles Antigone and Plato s Apology which suggests that they give both similar views with the existing idea of different higher authority in mind. Because of the unresolved feud between the law and civil disobedienceRead MorePresident Of The United States1018 Words   |  5 PagesPresident of the United States, a position in government that requires man to be truthful, trustworthy, and proper. A position that is forbidden for wrong, and improper beings such as criminals or law-breakers. In this case however, a man by the name of Abraham Lincoln was given the position not suited for him, and he has misused it to its core. Lincoln denied Habeas Corpus which is one of the many important rights that people have when imprisoned. He has denied the first amendment rights set forthRead MoreAnalysis Of Antigone Actions Were Just 1254 Words   |  6 PagesHigh School Debate Speech: â€Å"Antigone’s Actions Were Just† While one can argue against the law of the gods and the laws of man, there is never a clear answer, as to which one is superior. In defense of her position, Antigones decision to bury her brother was justified because the laws of the gods, as well as respect for the deceased, triumph over the laws of the state. Morals are often independent and separate from human laws, but they should always be followed. Creon had no right to give an orderRead MoreAnalysis Of The Book The Of Socrates 1223 Words   |  5 Pagesthe bear or loin who have no knowledge. Now that we’ve taken a closer look at these definitions we can now shift our focus over to Crito’s argument. Crito’s first argument is not very convincing as it has primarily concerns itself with Crito’s own selfish concerns. He gives two basic reasons why Socrates should come with him and escape. One being that he’ll be deprived of a great friend who’ll never be replaced if they don’t leave there. And second being most people will think that Crito could haveRead MoreIs Civil Disobedience Enough?2173 Words   |  9 PagesHe claimed this was his necessary act of civil disobedience. However the passive nature of civil disobedience is no longer as effective in making change in comparison to more abrasive political demonstrations such as lobbying, and rioting. The importance of political action resonates strong within my own personal beliefs because I have been a first hand witness of these injustices. I have seen my latino family struggle and fight for equity within the system that does not even recognize their existenceRead MoreThe Immense Character Development in Antigone by Sophocles Essay examples1539 Words   |  7 Pagesfighting. Claiming that Polynices was a traitor, he shows complete refusal to grant Polynices a respectable and worthy service. Clearly disagreeing with Creon’s inexcusable demands, Antigone declares she will bury Polynices herself so that his soul can be at peace. Entirely aware of the consequences and dangers of this action, which include death, she goes forward vowing her love for her family. Antigone shows strength and determination towards her brother. However, her growing sense of pride leadsRead MoreThe Issue Of Sexual Practices1832 Words   |  8 Pageswidely - the conflict between these three inv ite debates about what kind of behaviour is correct. It was originally believed that the individual was made up of both the physical and spiritual side. The spiritual mind was regarded as having a higher importance than the physical element, as the existence of the body could be doubted but the mind and soul was â€Å"the essence† of the person, that is capable of belief, hope, thought and doubt. Sex was frowned upon and regarded as unholy as it drew attentionRead MoreEssay on Japanese Internment After Pearl Harbor2441 Words   |  10 Pagesand China reinforced this feeling that the Western world was facing what came to be known as â€Å"yellow peril†. This was reflected in the media, movies and in literature and journalism.4 Anti-Oriental public opinion gave way to several declarations and laws to restrict Japanese prosperity on American land. Despite the prejudice and ineligibility to obtain citizenship the Issei 5 stayed on. They worked hard, bettered their economic condition and raised their own families. The Japanes e prosperity was seen